This is the second of my Five Keys. It’s called Listen, then Think. Listen, then Think, listen to your feelings, then think before you act, is a way of relating to emotions in the moment, and probably the only part of the Five Keys that it would be helpful to actually commit to memory. Listen, then think. Three words. That’s it.
It is easiest to see how Listen, then Think works by looking at what happens when a person doesn’t do one or other of them. You probably know someone, real or fictitious, who does not think before acting on their feelings. “He looked at me funny, so I hit him; I fancied her, so I had an affair”. Not thinking before you do things can lead to a life that is very exciting, but you might also do quite a lot of things that you regret.
People who do not listen to their feelings, on the other hand, tend to ignore, mistrust or second-guess them. “I didn’t like what was happening, but I went ahead anyway so as not to cause a fuss.” Not listening to your feelings can lead you into life situations that turn out not to suit you very well. The comedy series Peep Show provides great examples of both of these ways of being. Mark marries Sophie, whom he no longer loves, because he is too embarrassed to say how he really feels. Jeremy sleeps with Mark’s sister because he takes pride in his own impulsivity. “Why should I take responsibility for my actions?” says Jeremy. “I just do my actions”.
One of the reasons Peep Show is such compelling TV is that Mark and Jeremy mis-relate to their feelings in opposite ways. Mark does not listen, and Jeremy does not think. They are highly entertaining characters, but you probably wouldn’t want to be either of them.
When clients come to see me, something I hear quite a lot is: “I want to get better at controlling my emotions”. What they really mean by this is “I want to get better at controlling how I react to my emotions, what I do in response to them”. This is an important distinction, because emotions generally happen prior to conscious thought. If you are walking down a path and you see a snake, you will feel shock in your body before you think the word ‘snake’; the emotion has already permeated your being before thinking has even got its trousers on. Emotions land on cognitive ground, of course, and that ground can shift over time. A traffic jam is less annoying if you no longer believe being late is very bad. But, in the moment, Listen, Then Think still holds.
At this point we need to ask what emotions are actually for. Why do we even have them? The easiest way to answer this is to imagine what life would be like if we didn’t have them. On the most basic level, if you couldn’t tell what food you liked or didn’t like, you would have a pretty good chance of being poisoned. Similarly, if you lacked the ability to feel good emotionally, how would you know what to do in your life, or whom to do it with? More difficult emotions are useful too. Anger, or the possibility of anger, a sense of ‘I don’t like that’, helps us to set boundaries, say ‘no’ and defend ourselves if necessary. Fear tells us what might be dangerous; regret what we should do differently next time. Sadness is a little bit different, in that it just asks us to stay still and be with it, but knowing when not to move is important too.
Emotions allow us to navigate the world. And we, as humans, also have advanced cognition: we get to think and plan. What is the best way for me to act on this feeling? Should it be immediately, or in a bit? By doing Listen then Think, we use our entire humanity to respond to our feelings, rather than just reacting in the spur of the moment. If you watch Peep Show, you will see that both Mark and Jeremy navigate extremely badly, and after twelve years and 54 episodes end up exactly where they started: having an argument in Mark’s flat. It is important to realise that these are not stupid men, the show would not be half so funny if they were. What they are is emotionally illiterate. Listen, Then Think allows us to do things differently and move through our lives in the way that is right for us The word ‘emotion’ is almost the same as ‘motion’, after all.
If you’d like to, have a think back on your own life now. Were there any times when you had a feeling, but did not listen to it? Or how about when you did listen, but did not think before doing something in response? What happened for you after each of those times? Now see if you can remember a time when you managed to listen, then think. Did that go any better?
What if, with your emotional self, you already contain the compass that you need to navigate the world, and live the life that is best for you?
